Spinal Stenosis vs. Herniated Disc: Key Differences

Back pain, leg pain, and numbness are symptoms shared by many spinal conditions. Two of the most common — spinal stenosis and herniated disc — can produce similar symptoms but are fundamentally different conditions with distinct causes, presentations, and treatment approaches. If you have been told you have one of these conditions, or if you are trying to understand your symptoms, this guide will help you distinguish between them.

What Is a Herniated Disc?

A herniated disc occurs when the inner gel-like core of a spinal disc pushes through its outer layer and presses on a nearby nerve. It is most common in the lumbar region at L4-L5 or L5-S1 and typically develops from a combination of disc degeneration and a precipitating event such as a heavy lift, twist, or traumatic injury. Herniated discs most often affect younger and middle-aged adults, typically between the ages of 30 and 50.

What Is Spinal Stenosis?

Spinal stenosis is a narrowing of the spinal canal — the space housing the spinal cord and nerve roots. Rather than being caused by a single event, stenosis develops gradually over years as part of the aging process. Contributing factors include thickening of spinal ligaments, bone spur formation, facet joint enlargement, and disc degeneration. It most commonly affects adults over 50 to 60 years of age.

Comparing the Symptoms

Effect of Movement and Position

This is one of the clearest distinguishing features between the two conditions. With a herniated disc, pain typically worsens with sitting, forward bending, and prolonged static positions. Many patients feel better standing or walking. With spinal stenosis, pain worsens with standing and walking — a condition called neurogenic claudication — and relieves with sitting or bending forward.

Pattern and Age of Onset

Herniated disc pain is often acute and well-localized, frequently felt on one side, with sudden onset following a physical event. Spinal stenosis pain is typically diffuse, bilateral, and comes on gradually over time. Herniated disc is more common in adults aged 30–50, while spinal stenosis predominantly affects adults over 50–60.

How Are They Diagnosed?

Both conditions are diagnosed with a combination of clinical examination and MRI imaging. MRI allows visualization of disc material pressing on nerves (herniation) as well as narrowing of the spinal canal (stenosis). In some patients, both conditions coexist — a disc herniation can occur on a background of existing stenosis.

Treatment Differences

Herniated discs frequently resolve on their own as the herniated material shrinks over time, with treatment focusing on pain and inflammation management, physical therapy, and epidural steroid injections. Surgery via microdiscectomy is considered for persistent neurological symptoms. Spinal stenosis does not resolve spontaneously as it is caused by bony and ligamentous changes. However, symptoms can often be well-controlled conservatively. When surgery is needed, lumbar decompression (laminectomy) is the procedure of choice.

When to See a Spine Specialist

Whether your symptoms point toward a herniated disc, spinal stenosis, or another condition, accurate diagnosis is the foundation of effective treatment. Dr. Han Jo Kim, MD provides comprehensive spine evaluations and individualized treatment plans at his New York practice. Schedule your consultation today.

Related reading: Herniated Disc: Symptoms, Diagnosis & Treatment | Lumbar Spinal Stenosis: Symptoms & Treatment | What Is Sciatica? Causes, Symptoms & Treatments